If many different people say the same thing about a product, it is worth paying attention. It is interesting to see how different people value different aspects of a product. Jewelry is another category where quality can be very different from photos. If they reply politely and give detailed answers, I feel more relaxed. For coats and blazers I usually go one size up if I want to layer sweaters under them.
If anyone is interested in real user experiences, I sometimes write short notes about the shops I test.
You can find one of the pages here:
visit this page
Some pieces look shiny online but feel like plastic when you open the package. At least here we can see more honest opinions and not only polished marketing content. Some care only about style, others focus on comfort and durability. Sometimes I still make mistakes with size, so a friendly exchange policy is very helpful. Sometimes I do not mind waiting longer if the price is fair and the quality is solid. Trendy pieces are fun, but I only buy them when the price is reasonable.
Just sharing my personal feedback.